New Enterprise Name

 

New Enterprise Description

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Primary Contact Name

 

Phone

Sponsoring Individual or Organization

 

 

Address

 

Email

City

 

State/Province

FAX

Country

 

Postal Code

 

Instructions:

 

Fill out the Program Snapshot table that follows.  Do not attempt to create a full-blown business plan.  That will come later.  The purpose of this exercise is to communicate the essence of your business concepts, and to test them against the tough criteria that will be applied by a potential investor.  Assistance with this exercise is available upon request.

 

After you have completed the Program Snapshot, score it, using the Self-Scoring Matrix provided.  Using this feedback, revise your Snapshot until you are satisfied with the score.  Next, have someone else score it for you.  Again, revise as necessary.

 

When you really like the results, attach it to your Application for Provisional Membership in VTKnowledgeWorks, and schedule your initial review with

 

Jim Flowers, Director

VTKnowledgeWorks

1715 Pratt Drive, Suite 2800

Blacksburg, VA  24060

540-443-9100

jim.flowers@vtknowledgeworks.com
Program Snapshot

 

Market

Market Opportunity (basic drivers of growth)

 

 

 

Target Definition (specific end users)

 

 

 

Growth Potential (how big the company can become)

 

 

 

Competition (strengths, weaknesses)

 

 

 

Marketing & Sales (how you will promote yourself, who will close the deals, etc)

 

 

 

Product/Service

Product Status (idea, prototype, early sales complete, etc.)

 

 

 

Value Proposition (“unfair” competitive advantage)

 

 

 

Product/Service Differentiation & Intellectual Property Protection (what makes it special, and how is that protected)

 

 

 

 


 

Human Resources

Management Team (who will do each key job)

 

 

 

Organization Concept (how will the team grow)

 

 

 

Special Needs

 

 

 

Financial Considerations

Economic Model (how will you make money)

 

 

 

Financing Requirements (how much outside capital will be required to reach profitability)

 

 

 

 


Self-scoring Matrix

 

 

0

2

4

6

8

10

 

Market

Market opportunity

No visible market

Small, low growth market

Small stagnating or large diminishing market

Small growing or large mature market

Small booming or large growing market

Large booming market

 

Customer understanding

Target group and needs not defined or understood

Target group vaguely defined

Target group defined but hard to recognize

Market segmentation stated and target group defined

Market segmentation and target group defined

Market segmentation presented persuasively; target group well defined

 

Growth potential

Zero, looks like a disaster

Sales > $5M in 5 years

Sales > $10M in 5 years

Sales > $25M in 5 years

Sales > $50M in 5 years

Sales > $100M in 5 years

 

Competition

Very tough, entrenched competition

Tough active competition or expected in the short term

Avg. competition active or expected in the near term; tough competition expected in the medium or long term

Weak competition active or expected in the short term; tough competition expected in the medium or long term

Weak competition active or expected in the short term; average competition expected in the medium or long term

No competition established or expected in the short term or weak competition expected in the medium or long term

 

Marketing & Sales

No real strategy

Unclear or unconvincing strategy

Individual ideas OK, but overall strategy unclear

Overall strategy clear, but details could be tricky

Clear and complete marketing strategy

Very convincing marketing strategy presented with high market penetration expected

 

 


 

 

0

2

4

6

8

10

 

Product/Service

Status

Idea sketched only roughly

Idea clearly described; plausible but no working demonstration of product

Alpha product developed and functionality tested

Beta product tested; necessary product refinements identified and development

End product defined and working to customer satisfaction; commercial sales are being achieved

End product fully commercialized, efficiently produced and ready for wide distribution to customers

 

Value proposition

Not addressed

Addressed but not validated

Addressed but has marginal value

Value clear but low to customer

Medium value validated

High value validated

 

Product/service differentiation and intellectual property protection

Sustainable differentiation to competing products on the market unclear or not stated

Considerations for differentiation evident (e.g., patents, protective rights)

Definite differentiation strategy formulated (e.g., patents, protective rights)

Effective differentiation strategy defined, first steps already taken (e.g., patent application filed)

Key measures for sustained differentiation introduced (e.g., multiple patents pending)

Significant measures for sustained differentiation (e.g., strong patents issued)

 

Human Resources

Team

No notable domain experience or abilities

Little notable domain experience or abilities

One team member with notable domain experience

Several team members with notable domain experience, but all major areas not covered yet

Team covers all major areas with very good experience/abilities

Team covers all major areas with excellent experience/abilities and high profile CEO heading the company

 

Organization

No organization presented

Organization stated but poor delegation of tasks and responsibilities

Largely adequate organization but open issues to address

Fully adequate organization

Fully adequate organization and competent partners

Excellent organization and strong partners

 

Special Needs – Technical or Professional

 

 

Failure to fill certain slots could doom the enterprise

Special needs not addressed at all

Special needs identified

Special needs identified and under consideration

Special needs identified and fully-addressed

No special needs

 

 

 

0

2

4

6

8

10

 

Financial Considerations

Economic Model

 

 

 

Critical assumptions not presented

Planning and expected return based on hunches

Planning and expected return backed by some research

Planning and expected return backed by serious research but return is not attractive

Planning and expected return backed by serious research and return is modestly attractive

Planning and expected return backed by serious research and return is highly attractive

 

Launch Stage Financing Requirements

>$3M required

$1M-$3M required

$250K-$1M required

<$250K required

<$100K required

No outside funds needed

 

 

0

4

8

12

16

20

 

Overall Impression

 

On the whole, little point in pursuing: the business concept has little potential, the planning is sketchy, and the presentation careless

Contains several interesting aspects, but in its present form, the overall concept is not very persuasive

Contains a number of interesting elements possibly worth pursuing, but overall the concept has clear weaknesses in potential, planning, or presentation

On the whole, interesting and possibly worth pursuing but planning and presentation need improvement

On the whole, attractive and worth pursuing; a business concept with great potential, good prospects for success, and a convincing presentation

On the whole, highly attractive and persuasive in all main aspects; a business concept with great potential, excellent prospects for success, and an exciting presentation

 

Total Score – 150 is perfect